They had their best year ever. Record revenue. The owner told the whole team at the holiday party and everyone cheered.
Your Best Year Was a Trap
Record revenue went on the holiday-party banner. Six months later, two top employees were gone, margins were down, and the line of credit was maxed.
In this episode
The revenue was real. So were the costs, overtime, and fear of having to do it all again.
That was not the company’s best year. It was a trap wearing a trophy.
In Episode 22 of From Burnt Out to Bought Out, Jon and Ryan break down why a record-revenue year can still be a terrible business year. They examine Dale’s 10 straight months of overtime, explain why “revenue is just the noise it makes on the way through,” and compare two $5 million businesses one keeping $1 million and the other keeping $150,000. You’ll learn how to judge growth using three practical tests: profitability, durability, and repeatability.
If you hit your revenue target but sacrificed your margin, cash, team, or sanity to get there this one's for you.
Chapters
Transcript · full conversation
Six months later, two of his best people had quit, his margin was down, his line of credit was maxed, and he was terrified. Not a failing of having to do that year again because the number on the banner was the only thing about that year that was actually good. Today, why your best year might be the most dangerous thing that ever happened to your business and how to tell a real best year from a trap wearing a trophy.
Welcome to From Burnout to Bought Out, the podcast for business owners who are tired of being the hardest working, lowest paid employee in their own company. I'm Jon, joined as always by Ryan and together we've spent years inside owner-led businesses helping founders go from running on fumes to running a business that actually runs without them. Every episode we break down the real problems nobody talks about. The burnout, the bottlenecks, the blind spots, and show you what it looks like to build a business that's profitable, sellable, and doesn't need you in the building every day to survive. Whether you're grinding through a plateau, thinking about an exit, or just trying to take a vacation without your phone blowing up, you're in the right place. Let's get into it.
This episode has to make people mad, right? Like we're trying our damnedest to get record revenue. It's the dream. So how can this make your best year a trap? So composite story, we're going to call this guy Dale. Record top line, you know, to get there, took work he'd normally decline, discounted to wins, ran the team on overtime for 10 straight months, right? Call back to our, you know, you're the cheapest. This guy actually caused the problem himself by discounting, right? Fell into the price trap just because he wanted a banner for a deadline, right? But the revenue was real, but now so was the cost. Margin fell because new work was cheap work, right? Cash got tighter because low margin growth eats cash, and the team was fried. Overtime for 10 months straight, right? The thing is he didn't have his best year. He had a record year, but a terrible business year at the same time, and that can happen. So nobody caught it in the moment because they were chasing revenue, which is the loudest, fastest, most visible number in the company.
They had a countdown, right? They had it on the wall, right? We're getting there, we're getting there, we're getting there. The problem is that they sacrificed profitability. Dangerous. How did nobody notice that was happening though, right? Like you got all these things going on, those celebrations going on, and then suddenly the bad stuff hits, but I mean like, don't people notice? Are there indicators along the way? There are indicators, but they weren't looking for them. They were just chasing one number at all costs, right? Your balance sheet will tell you that things aren't working well. Your income statement will tell you it's not working, right? Your bank account will tell you you're getting a problem, but sometimes these are lagging indicators, right? It doesn't happen overnight. It's a slow deterioration in some points, but when you're focused on one thing, it's the law of attraction where you kind of just kind of see that everywhere, and that's all that matters. Yeah, I get it. Okay, so can we put some tests in place so that we can tell whether there's a difference between a trap and actually a genuinely best year? Yeah, so there's three things that you can look at to see whether this is actually your best year or if it is a trap, right? One is profitability, right? Did your margin hold or grow? If your revenue is growing, your margin should as well. If your margins are dropping, you're just taking work to catch that number, right? You're discounting things. You want to be the cheapest and get that revenue at all costs. The other one is, you know, is it durable? Did the growth strengthen the business or did it strain it, right? Did it burn out your folks with 10 months of overtime or is it solid growth that you can maintain over a long period of time? The other one is, is it repeatable, right? Did we just grab work to grab work? Was it a one-time project or is it a lucky whale? Is it a spike, you know, or is it solid? Our marketing is working.
We're getting the right type of clients out there. We're delivering the project on time. Our folks aren't burnt out and here we go, right? It's recurring monthly revenue. It's several projects, not one of those kinds of things. So again, profitable, durable, repeatable, profitable, durable, repeatable, and check your numbers. You got it. Awesome. Time for Ryan's fun fact. So fun fact, there's a principle called good heart's law.
When a measure becomes a target, it stops being a good measure. The moment you optimize for a single number, people find ways to hit the number that have nothing to do with the thing you actually want. So chasing revenue is the target basically corrupts it. Exactly. When you make revenue the only goal, you'll get revenue, but you'll discount, you'll take bad work, you'll burn out your team. You hit the number at all costs, but you'll lose your business in the process.
That is crazy. Good moment for a word from our sponsor. And today it's Esther's Coffeehouse. Look at this, wearing the hat right in downtown Messina in North Country, New York. And it fits the episode because tonight is about slowing down enough to look at the right scoreboard. Esther's is a slow down kind of joint. It is. They roast their own beans in-house. They make the drinks and treats from scratch.
And Chef Kathy's pastries are so good, the locals say you'll think you're wandering into good old Montreal. High praise from this show given the company. Yes, indeed. Maple matcha, cold brew, silly sodas, real fruit smoothies, the whole creative menu. And they've got genuinely stylish swag, the kind of mug and merch you actually want on your head and in your hand, not the kind you hide in a drawer. A local shop that roasts its own coffee is a business that measured the right thing. They didn't chase volume. They chased good. Esther's Coffeehouse, Messina, New York, estherscoffeehouse.com. Go slow down for an hour.
Where the hell's the phone number? No, they don't answer the phone in a coffeehouse. You're too busy relaxing. You're serving.
But look at that. Look at the coordination. You realize what I had to do to be wearing this hat at this precise moment in time? Let's see. You wrote the episode with all the questions and stuff. You need to sponsor Esthers. Oh, yeah.
And a lot of coordination, John. And I got the hat from my wardrobe and I put it on my head. OK, so, yeah, not that amazing, I guess.
You keep calling the revenue a vanity number. Obviously, we've talked about that in the past and previous episodes, but it is the number everybody leads with. Make the case that it's lying to us. All right. So revenue is sexy. Right. It tells you how much money passed through your business. Right. But it tells you nothing about how it stayed or how hard it was to get or whether you can do it again. Right. It's such a liar. But it's such a thing that we talk about. You know, I did 10 million last year. You know, I took it over from my old man or my or my mom. It was three million. Now we're at three point two million. Right. Like it's a sense of pride. Right. So let's take an example of two businesses that do five million dollars in annual sales. Right. One keeps one million. It's saying it's repeatable. It's it's monthly recurring.
The other one keeps 150 and it's exhausted and lucky. Right. Which one would you rather buy? The one that keeps a million bucks or the one that keeps 150? Right. So revenue is what you took in. Profit is what you keep. Cash is what you actually use.
And that's the thing. Revenue is just the noise it makes on the way through. Right. The profit needs revenue. First point is true, but it's besides the point. I'm not saying ignore revenue, but I'm saying just don't celebrate it alone.
There are other things there. Right. So what really needs to belong on that banner isn't just the revenue target.
It's margin or profit by customer or cash generated or revenue by employee or customer retention. Those are the numbers that matter. Those are the numbers that turn you $150,000 bottom line business to one million and on the same amount of revenue.
Got it. Understood. OK, let's track those other other metrics, not just revenue.
But so isn't there some collateral damage if we are just chasing revenue the whole time? What is the actual damage? What is a revenue chasing best year really cost us besides just thin margin? It costs you one bad, slow month that your business could go under. Right. If your if your margins are so deteriorated that you've discounted just for that, it burns out your team. Usually you're attracting the wrong type of customer. So now they're talking about pricing, not quality. Right. There's a whole slew of stuff, but it's going to show up in your bank account. Right. You're going to be the lowest paid person in the employee because your margins are so thin and stretched out that you have to pay everybody first and you last and most of the time there's no money for you.
Gotcha. So, yeah, I mean, keep keep going on that. Let's let's what is the true cost of of just going after the trophy? I think, you know, it's it's burnout.
Turnover, not only just your employees, but also your, you know, your customers are going to turn over like crazy, you're going to probably need to add debt to make to make next week's payroll. Right. You know, obviously it's a huge cash stream.
Right. And so you're going to have that 20 year old van that you can never replace. Right. That just looks bad and worse and worse and worse. And then, God forbid, something happen. Right. Where are you going to get the money? You know, and then you're going to get those complainers, those two star, one star reviews because they can't give you zero because someone else sold the same product that gave you the same service, you know, for fifty dollars cheaper. Right. And I think also is you're setting yourself up for a trap of expectation.
Right. Is that we've got to hit this number at all costs. Right. What happens if you just if if you have a record sales year, but you don't hit your you don't hit your your number. Right. You're off by two percent.
Right. You just completely deflated the entire morale of the company or yourself over, you know, fifty thousand dollars, one hundred thousand dollars, whatever that might be. So I think that when you start setting these expectations based upon sales, it promotes just a negative cycle throughout the entire organization.
Yeah, that is so true. And I've been part of so many organizations, especially in the sales and marketing side. Right. Like that. That's the number we want. Would make number to chase up on the scoreboard, get after it.
Right. And it's not just about the miss. You know, I think it you're quite right.
It sets the tone for everything in the organization that the only thing matters is revenue, not quality. Right. Not looking after your people, not making sure that your product is deep and that you got evolving products coming out.
There's so many other things to focus on as well. So I've been part of a number of organizations that are sales first and it's it's never good. Yeah, I think we're going to roll across through to the marketing tip of the week, which I thought I'd change the name of it from Emtow.
Emtow doesn't have that much of a ring. What about John's two cents? What do you think, Ryan? Or is it a dollar forty Canadian? Two cents is a dollar forty Canadian. Two cents Canadian.
A dollar. Sorry. One cent forty U.S. Got my exchange rate wrong there.
Well, do not let this guy near your numbers, folks. Right. My one cent forty U.S. All right. Time for marketing tip of the week. We're going to change the name of Ryan. It's going to be John's two cents.
Yeah, it's a Canadian, so it's discounted. Yeah, that's right. One cent forty.
Something like that. Tip of the week. It's the antidote to flying blind, which is what this whole episode is about.
Track your lead source. Every single lead, you got to understand where it came from. You can ask him, how did you hear about us? It's the most valuable question most businesses forget to ask.
Without it, you have no idea which marketing channel actually works. So you pour your money into channels on a hunch and you call it a strategy. It's the same disease as celebrating revenue, measuring the loud thing instead of the true thing.
You are 100 percent right. Ninety days of real lead source data going after it meticulously is going to tell you precisely where to spend and where to stop spending. So one step this week at one required field to your intake form or your phone script that captures how every new lead found you.
Start this week. In 90 days, the data is going to start helping you make decisions. So that was worth a solid two cents, not the discounted one.
Oh, that's kind of you. Thanks. Yeah.
I mean, I'm not going to say all of them are going to be like that. So no, no, no, you know, they'll vary. It's hit and miss 100 monkeys in a typewriter.
You know, you've only used that expression about 10 times. I use it every day. And we need more material.
I'll call that. Excellent. One more word about our sponsor, Esther's Coffee House in Messina, New York.
This whole episode is a warning against running yourself into the ground for a number on a banner. And the antidote is almost embarrassingly simple. Sometimes you just need to stop and sit down with a good cup of coffee.
And Esther's is built for exactly that. Downtown gathering spot. They roast their own.
They want you to actually stay a while, not just grab and sprint back to the grind. That's what Dunkin Donuts is for. That's right.
Grab a bag of beans on your way out so you can slow down at home too. Plus the swag, which again is genuinely nice. I don't say that about most coffee shop merch.
You've got a version of this. I can feel it. As a Canadian, I came from a place where the entire culture is basically built around somewhere warm to drink a hot beverage and complain about the weather with people you like.
A good coffee house is civic infrastructure where I'm from. That's my one and I stand by it. That's your one.
And honestly, a heartfelt one. Esther's Coffee House or Coffee Houses. It should be pronounced, John.
20 Andrew Street, Messina, New York. Esther'sCoffeeHouse.com. Go find the good scoreboard and a good latte. The number is 555-555-5555.
Remember that when they used to put that on there? Five, five, five. I have no idea what you're talking about. Oh my god.
You never saw like the Brady Bunch? Every area code was 555 because it doesn't exist in the U.S.? Uh, no. No. No Brady Bunch for me.
I grew up in England. Wow. Okay.
Benny Hill. Five, five, five. Yeah, that works.
That works. And the music. Perfect.
Yep. Well, whatever you say, seeing as you're a celebrated author now. Right? Let's get in there.
Oh yeah. Oh yeah. Everybody, all five listeners, Ryan is actually published and you can go buy his book.
It's fantastic. Coming out March something. That's some year.
Nothing like accuracy, right? Yeah, the publishing process is longer than the actual writing of the book. Well, that takes some doing then. Good stuff.
Well, we'll share the link, share more information. We'll get a short code, something like that, so people can go out and actually buy the book. Help Ryan become a celebrated award-winning author.
It's great content. We're going through it all in these podcasts. Really.
All right. So let's make sure we don't leave people scared of growing. This is about engineering a scenario that actually creates what you need.
So how do you build that? How do you create a best year that's actually good and the kind that you want to repeat? So you've got to grow the right number on purpose. Right? I get choked up about it. It's an emotional moment, folks.
The best year worth having, it grows profit and cash and it's just not revenue anymore. You have the same energy, but now we're actually... I mean, I want to see an extra zero in my bank account. I don't know about you, right? It's getting weird now.
Right? So we actually had some fan mail about the cheapest episode and about, should I match the person's price? And I've had this conversation a lot with other business owners is that they think that more sales will get them out of all their problems. And as the listeners know, that's not the case. And we're talking about that exact thing here.
It's got to be intentional sales. Sales that you don't discount. Sales that you don't price match.
Sales that you don't sacrifice your margin. Right? Don't incentivize your sales people on sales metrics. Incentivize them on gross profit metrics.
Right? So that they can't discount things so low that actually cost you money for that sale. Right? So make sure that you have safeguards in place, like gross margin. Right? We want to make sure that we have a 40% gross profitability.
Period. You cannot discount below this mark to get the sale. Right? Or make that sale intentional.
So sure, I'll discount this to you. But that means that I'm going to have a, you know, you're a repeat customer or you're a customer that if I get this project, it's going to lead to something that's 10 times bigger. Right? Yeah.
Right? So that, you know, you have to keep those things in mind. Create a lead in or, I mean, the first case there, having a pro forma review of each individual project. Right? Then you sit down as a team and you analyze it.
Make sure the numbers are actually there before you get the deal in front of people. Exactly. Exactly.
And, you know, we don't want to discount our way so that that's what the people expect. Right? Is that we'll fall into that trap. So you've got to protect your margin.
You also have to protect your capacity. Right? We want to use our folks for profitable work. We don't want to have to pay 10 months of overtime making 4% margin.
Right? I'd rather have my folks work 35 hours a day on something that's going to get them 40% margin. Right? It's far more profitable and I can keep up with everybody else and give them competitive wages. Right? And a good work-life balance.
Also, you've got to focus on growing your best work, not all work. Right? Pick your highest margin, best customers. That's the stuff you should be growing.
Right? The small margin stuff, maybe get somebody in the door. But then we're getting them over to something that's more profitable. Right? Recurring.
Those kind of things. And make it repeatable. Grow your systems.
Make sure that a junior person can do senior level work. Right? This growth isn't necessarily slower than chasing dollar after dollar, but it's more profitable. Right? It's going to help you in the long run so that you'll be around three years from now, not having to worry about payroll like you're doing now.
Right? So focus on those things. That will be your best year ever. Awesome.
Okay. Someone's driving home. They're sitting there.
They're realizing last year's record year nearly broke them. What is the one thing they can do this week? Ask yourself three questions. Was it profitable? Was it durable? And was it repeatable? And write down the honest answer to each.
If it passes all three, congratulations. It's real. Now go engineer it.
Go get another one on purpose. If not, it was a trap. If you're still trying to chase that, this revenue or this year, right? This perfect year.
Change your metric. Change your metric on the wall. Okay.
Revenue fine, but gross profitability, net income, right? Number of employees, revenue by employee, ideal customers, right? Growing the things that's actually going to make it your best year. Not just the highest sales number, right? And I think along with that is pick something that's really going to reflect if it was your best year or not. So did you maintain or increase your profit margin or simply this, your bank accounts, right? Or were you able to reduce your debt, right? Instead of add to it.
That is a year worth chasing. Got it. Yeah.
And back to your earlier references, get those other metrics on the banner, right? Margin, profit per customer, cash generated, revenue per employee, customer retention, et cetera, et cetera. Those things are key for being able to understand the progress you're making. Well said, sir.
That's worth three cents. Well, I just repeated. That's excellent.
I get three cents for repeating something you said earlier. Right. There you go.
But with a Canadian discount, so it's really worth two. Yeah. Well, I'll put that into renaming a lake that we used to have naming rights to.
Recover the lake fund. All right. Let's take away, Ryan.
A best year measured only in revenue can be the most dangerous thing that happens to your business. Revenue is a vanity scorecard. It tells you what passed through, but not what you kept, not how hard it was, you know, not how much you burnt out your team, right? A record built on discounting, bad work.
It's not achievable, right? It's horrible. And the payment doesn't necessarily come due right then and there. It takes its toll later on.
But a real best year passes a few tests, profitability, durability, repeatability, if that's a word, right? You miss one of those and you had an expensive year, not a great one. So instead of putting revenue on that banner, put profit, put cash, put least amount of, you know, zero accidents in the last 365 days, right? Those are the things that really will build a year that you can grow upon. So stop chasing the top number and start winning in your own business.
Awesome. Great advice. Now, if we could just go ahead and do it, if it was that easy, right? Yeah, you know, it's all, there's a lot of nuances in everything that we, all the advice we give, right? Like it's easy to give the top line on it.
The real execution is a thing, execution and consistency across all of our advice points, right? That is the challenge. But I think you got to know where you're headed and people can then start to put these things in place. Absolutely.
And, you know, you hit a bump in the road, okay, keep going. Yeah. Right.
It's never, nothing's ever perfect and nothing's a linear line. But if you start focusing on the right things, you know, our listeners, they have great business acumen. Focus on the right things.
Boy, sky's the limit. Yep. 100% right.
And it's complimenting the teams as well. Like, you know, they know what they're good at, right? You guys listening, you know what you're good at. You know, get the team members that compliment, you know, what you do so you can build an award winning kind of roster of players on your team.
And away you go. Just keep working at it. Keep going.
That's all you can do. You are the engine. That's it.
Excellent. So I think I might be in the hot seat next week. Yeah.
You know, and then thank you for giving everybody four warnings. So if you want to take next week off, you'll know ahead of time. Yeah.
Yeah. It'll just be by immediate family that I get to chat with. We're going to talk about branding, the importance of branding.
Right. We're not talking tattoos, right? Whatever it takes to get your business out there. Like, if it takes tattoos, fair enough.
So if I have to put Synergy on my forehead, then I will. I thought that's why you're wearing your hat. That's right.
Esther's Coffeehouse. Come in and get yourself tattooed. That's right.
Love it. Good stuff. That's a wrap.
All right. Hasta luego. Yep.
Peace out. That's it for this episode of From Burnout to Bought Out. If something we said today hit home, don't just nod in agreement.
Pick one thing. The number you've been avoiding. The process that only lives in your head.
The conversation you've been putting off for six months. Do that one thing this week. That's how it starts.
And if you're not sure which one thing to pick, drop us a line. We'll happily point you in the right direction. New episodes drop every week.
Until next time, stop running the treadmill and start building something you can actually sell.
Your hosts
RyanFormer accountant, fractional CFO and Certified Exit Planning Advisor. Author of the forthcoming 3:17 AM. Co-founder of Synergy Solutions.
More about Ryan
JonMarketer and agency owner who has run his own businesses. Sits in the fractional CMO seat at Synergy Solutions and asks the questions on the show.
More about Jon